Google is still in the early stages of injecting ads into the Google Maps 3-pack. Google never met an ad it didn’t like, so the only question is when (not if) the map pack will become Times Square.
The thought of a pay-to-play local map scares the bejeezus out of many local business owners and local SEOs.
Will you lose your seat at the Local Feast to a big dumb corporation that can shovel more money into AdWords than you can? Or, if helping people with local SEO is your business – and you don’t do PPC – will you be lying in chalk?
No and no. Not if you apply a strategy (more on that in a second) that’s based on a few truths:
1. As long as there are local customers, local businesses, and the Web, there will always be local SEO. It’ll just continue to morph over time, as it always has.
2. Your “Google Maps” visibility has a huge amount of overlap with other areas of online marketing – particularly with your organic-search visibility (read: your links and content) and with how good you are at earning reviews on a variety of sites.
3. The local map is not the holy grail. Keep in mind that I make a living in large part by helping businesses get visible there, so I’m the last guy to say it’s not important. But I’ve seen people dominate the local pack and not get any new business. Also, Google can always mess it up (even more), lose the trust of searchers, and reduce the potential payoff. If your one source of leads is your Google local-pack rankings, you are mooning a lion.
4. Local SEO is not just about rankings (duh). When you need something, do you automatically hire whomever ranks #1? Neither do most people. Local searchers are not a captive audience. Most of them will dig until they find a business they trust. Visibility in Google is only one part of becoming that business.
Fine, but what do you do if Google’s local map becomes prohibitively expensive, or worthless, or disappears entirely? What’s left? Is it Van Halen without David Lee Roth?
Local SEO wouldn’t be lessened, or even all that different. If we write off the map results, your local SEO campaign becomes a combination of your work on the following:
- Branded search results. When people look up your business by name, can they immediately tell your site belongs to you and not to a sound-alike competitor? Are they impressed by your customers’ reviews of you on all the review sites that show up on page 1 for your name? Have you received any local press? Are you listed on niche sites?
- Organic visibility. It’s usually the business with the best organic visibility that ends up ranking best on the local map. Often, that comes down to strength of your links. But you may also want to write blog posts on extremely specific topics in your industry or city, or create good “location” or “city” pages, or both. Arguably even now you’re not necessarily better off if you rank well in the local pack but not in the organic results; they’re neck-and-neck. But if the local pack becomes a total trash heap, your organic visibility pays off even more, because people will go back to looking there for all non-ads search results – just as they did before Google Places came onto the scene.
- Barnacle SEO. Getting your Yelp, Facebook, YouTube, or other non-company-website, non-Google online properties to rank for “local” keywords can help you haul in more leads, even when your other rankings aren’t so good.
- Facebook. It’s slowly waded about shin-deep into the local pond, but there’s no reason to think the shirt isn’t coming off. It’s only getting more important, and there any many ways to use it to get more local customers.
- Other local search engines: Apple Maps and Bing Places and Yahoo.
- Local directories or review sites. Not the rinky-dink ones, but rather places like Yelp, Angie’s List, and maybe even nasty old YellowPages.
- Industry-specific directories or review sites. Zillow, Avvo, HealthGrades, TripAdvisor, DealerRater, etc. Those are the big names, but even small niches have directories, and you should pay attention to them.
- Sites and apps not yet created. Local search in general has gotten bigger over the years, not smaller. It’s become more of a part of everyone’s life, and will continue in that direction.
If Google’s local map results change significantly or go away, it’s not the beginning of the end, but maybe just the end of the beginning.
Now, I would be surprised if the local map ever becomes 100% pay-to-play, and I’m certain that it won’t change to that overnight.
But you still want a bunker plan. That means you need to stock up the bunker with MREs and batteries and road flares and ninja throwing stars and whatever else before all hell breaks loose.
That’s why, even if the local map-pack remains free and a meritocracy at least in theory, I suggest you work on the things I just described no matter what.
What are some important non-Google-Maps aspects of local SEO?
What’s in your “bunker plan,” in case the local map gets too pay-to-play?
Leave a comment!
Jason BARNARD says
Hey, great post. Influencing the SERPs for brand searches is a great way to go. Many business owners don’t even realise they CAN influence heavily what Google shows about them.
You got that right, Jason.
This raises some great questions. I believe in the old adage that one should never place all their eggs in one basket.
Location, location, location!
Schema, rich snippet elements, and geo data send important signals that help “location pages” rank locally. Believe what you want, but I defer to results-driven conclusions -vs- speculation, rumors, and what Google does or doesn’t do…
I agree about the eggs, Scott. Not sure what you mean by the last sentence, though.
A great many of the so called “authorities” (excluding you) claim that Google doesn’t consider schema and image alt properties when ranking pages. They claim this because Google says so. You know as well as I do Phil, that Google doesn’t just lay all their cards on the table… The last sentence simply means, do what works – not what other claim.
Since posting the original comment I have experienced tremendous ranking changes that are positive. The true “SECRET” is to make changes and wait – and don’t panic if negative results happen first. Wait for several days or a week to see how the changes work over the long haul 😉
Have a great day!
Tim Colling says
Hey thanks, Phil. A great article and an encouraging one too!
Hey, thanks, Tim.
Edgar Allen says
Phil…first of all, where can I get a can of pound cake MRE? (Ha!) In addition to all things SEO, this is also a good reminder that – if you actually score a site visitor, it’s probably a good practice to do everything possible to know who they are (email, SMS?)! Or, just work to make your site super sticky so they stay for a while. Or ask visitors to bookmark the site to make it easy to find again. Imagine putting all that work into pulling an actual human into your web and then releasing them back into the wild 99.9% of the time without any sort of tracking beacon? As most business websites do.
Jason BARNARD says
Rare that someone talks about humans !!!!!! Very good point 🙂
Email is the C-ration pound cake of online marketing 🙂
Word of mouth advertising is always the best route, always. As are alternative ways to market a product or business. Just off the cuff, my team is presently using pokemongo to bring in web traffic, and for brick and mortar clients, foot traffic – and it’s working. Like Scott says, not all eggs in one basket. Marketing is about using multiple approaches to bring business to your client, and testing, testing and more testing on what works the best. Cheers and thanks for the insight.
Word-of-mouth certainly is the heart and maybe the lungs. But you need the limbs, too.
Alan Timms says
Excellent post as always Phil! SEO work with or without a 3-Pack listing still makes a massive difference – in many cases 100+ extra phone calls each month so I don’t see it going away anytime soon. The two areas where I am seeing increased demand is email newsletters and Facebook advertising (I ignored it for a long time, but so many people ask me for it now I decided to do it properly to actually get some ROI). FB is a paid service … but not very expensive and it’s targeting is exceptional. If the 3-Pack does die … I think this is where most of us will end up 🙂
It’s useful to have many weapons in the armory, for sure. But just as email marketing has always had a place in the world and always will, so will good local (and non-local) SEO – whatever happens with the 3-pack.
Good topic, Phil, and you’ve raised a point I’d like to hear more of your thoughts on. You write:
“But if the local pack becomes a total trash heap, your organic visibility pays off even more, because people will go back to looking there for all non-ads search results – just as they did before Google Places came onto the scene.”
My question: I’ve heard quite a few people saying that ads in the pack will users back toward the organic results. I question this because I really doubt the average user will be able to tell the difference between paid and free listings, and won’t even care whether something is an ad or not if it connects them the business they want to contact. As Local SEOs, we are sensitive to ads in content, but my guess is that this stems from our job.
I really respect your insight and wonder if you would consider explaining in a bit more detail why you think average users would shy away from local pack ads. Do have a theory about this?
Hey Miriam, thanks for the great comment and question.
My point is Google only became Google once people started trusting the quality of the results, and that trust isn’t a bottomless reservoir. Any given user can only tolerate a certain number of late-running dentists with rude receptionists, or crooked contractors, or hotels with bedbugs, etc.
How many bad experiences a given person can take depends on the person and on how significant the bad experience was. People will dig a little farther into the SERPs once they think the extra trouble is less than the pain they could have avoided if they did their homework last time. The organic results sure have plenty of junk in them, too, but I’m just saying if more people can’t find what they’re looking for in the 3-pack, more of them will cast a wider net.
Now, I suspect Google is confident that the pool of local businesses that use AdWords isn’t worse than the ones that only want free visibility. (And I’d say that’s a safe assumption, to an extent.) I think this is where Eric Schmidt’s all-too-talked about “sort out the cesspool of the internet” comment comes in.
Okay, this makes more sense to me, you putting it this way. I always find it a hurdle to imagine how someone who isn’t like me (doesn’t work on the Internet) uses the Internet. I think those surveys people are doing now (did you see that DejanSEO piece on KW research?) are providing amazing insight into how the average user actually uses the web. Thanks, Phil!
Just my two shekels 🙂
Gosh, sorry for all the typos, Phil. I hate it when I’m sloppy 🙁
I didn’t even notice them, but I’m glad you made ’em – now I have company 🙂
Alex B says
Nice article Phil, and quite thought provoking.
As a natural pessimist, I would not be surprised to see Google cram the 3 pack with ads, perhaps even in exchange for reducing the space given to adwords listings in search results, but you’re absolutely right that we as marketers will just have to adapt to whatever Google throws at us.
‘Evolve or die’ may well have to become the mantra. But that’s fine, as local businesses will always need local customers, even if the methods to find them will change. Personally, I’m already looking into using Facebook and Twitter.
I agree that local SEOs need to be bendy. But I’d say we also need a core that doesn’t twist with Google’s whims – certain skills that can help clients no matter what. At least to me, it comes down to creativity. (I’m considering writing a post on the topic.)
Alex B says
Please do, I’d like to read your thoughts on the matter, and I’m sure others would too.
Topics like this interest me because I’m always keen on trying to stay ahead of the pack and ‘future proof’ my business as much as is possible, and this will always involve a certain element of going with the flow and adapting to whatever changes in SEM get thrown at us.
Brian Barwig says
Good topic here.
I dont think G will go full Pay to Play in Local yet, but I would not be surprised to see more ads than Local in a year or so. Google knows there is big $$ in that area and there isn’t many times G doesnt jump at the chance to monetize and collect more.
One of the best ways to preempt Pay to Play in Local is to diversify web traffic. Attain traffic/leads from other sources besides Google. There are certain industries where niche directories drive a good amount of traffic, YouTube, Facebook, Angies List, eBay and hundreds of others. It is going to depend upon the business and its goals, but it can be achievable.
I agree. Not sure how many true-blue niche directories drive significant traffic, but of course they can drive some traffic, and can be pretty important to customers’ due-diligence.
margaret ornsby says
Mooning a Lion! Never heard that before – what a hoot!
Have somewhat switched my notion on the idea of advertising in the local pack. The purist in me wants it organic, the realist says there’s so much spam in it in some industries, it shouldn’t even exist. So all Google is doing is turning the local pack back into the yellow pages, just a thin digital edition.
In the “old days”, no-one liked paying the YP big bills, but at least biz owners knew what they were up against if they weren’t in that yellow book. And many made that choice willingly.
I think the “free stuff” mentality of the Internet let a few people get lazy and they forgot the consistent effort it takes to market a business. Things are just coming full circle. Pay to play. Pay Google or pay your digital marketing agency. Either way, it’s pay – like it has been for centuries.
Good article reminding folks the local pack isn’t the be all and end all. And that what makes it all work is a *strategy*!
Great point re. “free stuff” thinking, Margaret.
I’ve sure noticed that thinking, too. Business owners can’t expect to get business just by being in business. The time when you could rank well in Google by just creating your listing was a holiday from Web history.