Quick Thoughts on the Google+ Local Review Pop-up

Like my post? Please share!

You may have noticed the annoying pop-up (or lightbox) that appears when you click on a business’s “reviews” link in the Google+ Local search results.


Andrew Shotland discovered this review pop-up two days ago.  How about taking a couple minutes to go read his two posts on it (if you haven’t already), and then loop back here.

Here are my initial thoughts on Google’s latest half-baked concoction:

It is going to evolve.  Fast.  Why?  Because Google is pushing people to write reviews, but it’s not getting people onto businesses’ Google+ Local pages.  There’s not even a link on the pop-up that you can click on to visit the Google page.  Businesses won’t use Google+ if their business pages are cloaked from potential customers, and customers won’t write reviews on Google+ unless and until the pop-up does a better job of enticing and inviting them to write a review (think Yelp).

There is no mention of Google+ – neither in the pop-up nor in the steps you’d follow to post a review from within the pop-up screen.  That fact alone is very weird, and suggests to me that all we’re seeing at this stage is a bare foundation that Google will build on.

Assuming the pop-up sticks around, Google will stuff it like a Thanksgiving turkey with knick-knacks meant to boost engagement with Google+ (“Follow” buttons, “+1” buttons, check-in invitations, etc.).

This is a slight bonus for business owners who have upgraded their Google+ Local listings to include all the social features, because the “Google+ page” link still takes searchers to the Google+ page, rather than to the pop-up.

Now is the time to get Google reviews from customers.  Last year wasn’t, because of the draconian review filters.  The review filters are still here, of course, but this year Google has made it clear that they really want more Plus reviews: First they relaxed the filter, then they put reviews front-and-center in the “new” Google Maps and in the local carousel, then they started showing the review stars again, and now they’ve introduced the pop-up.  Google is making it (relatively) easy for you and for your customers.

What are your thoughts on the pop-up?


  1. Hey Phil thanks for the post. I wasn’t sure if the pop up feature was new or not. I look at listing all day and everyday and sometimes things can become a blur.
    Well for me I’m kind of irritated that the new social features are not available to customers who manage more then 10 listings via the bulk management tool. I’ve been hearing that it’s coming but it’s been a while now since I’ve seen any updates regarding the topic

    • Hey Joseph,

      You’re quite welcome on the post. I know what you mean about how things become a “blur”!

      As you mention, it would be nice if Google would finally finish the transition to Google+ (and all the social features that come with it). Maybe we’ll be lucky and it will be done done some time next year…

  2. Clarification Question – “upgraded their Google+ Local listings to include all the social features” means what exactly? That you can post updates on the Google+ page for the business listing?


  1. Major Update? Missing Links to Google+ Local Pages and New Review Windows…

    Just finally getting time to check my feedreader. Phil posted about the review update and briefly mentioned the social connection and the G+ link too. Quick Thoughts on the Google+ Local Review Pop……

Speak Your Mind


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.